Abuse victim quits Vatican commission (2)

Survivor says she quit pope’s anti-abuse panel over frustrations with Curia

Her bravery was instrumental in encouraging other survivors to come forward and in forcing the Irish State to put in place four Commissions of Investigation which uncovered the dark, hidden world of clerical sexual abuse.

Clerical abuse survivor and campaigner Marie Collins said she resigned from the Pontifical Commission for the Protection of Minors because a group of people in the Vatican who had been obstructing its work, including not following recommendations from the Pope.

In a separate exclusive statement for NCR explaining her choice, Collins says she chose to leave the commission after losing hope that Vatican officials would cooperate with its work following a failure to implement a series of recommendations.

She said Ms Collins is recognised internationally as a woman of the highest integrity who harboured real hopes that her participation in the Vatican Commission would lead to genuine change at the very top of the Catholic Church. "I learned in a letter from this particular dicastery last month that they are refusing to do so", she said.

"Sometimes I feel the Pope does make mistakes, he's badly advised", said Collins, "But you're dependent in that position on those around you for advice".

Observers say the resignation of Collins puts the credibility of the commission in serious question. He says he understands that she felt "frustrations" that she was not listened to and that "as she says, there are some quarters in the Vatican ...that do not cooperate fully and with the speed necessary with the Commission".

Collins's departure and her depiction of high-level obstruction of change is an embarrassing blow to the pontiff's attempts to demonstrate that the Church is effectively combating a scourge that has profoundly damaged its image over recent decades.




In her resignation letter, Collins said she believed Francis had acted sincerely when he set up the panel in March 2014 with a brief to advise him on concrete steps to ensure the safety of minors within Catholic institutions.

Collins charged that a lack of cooperation on the part of other Vatican offices has stalled the Commission, preventing the implementation of policies meant to protect children and hold clergy accountable for committing or covering up abuse. Saunders had been critical of the commission's prospects from the start.

Between 2004 and 2014, the year the commission was founded, the Vatican defrocked 848 priests and disciplined 2,572 others accused of raping and molesting children. "If they don't have a survivor on that commission, it's like if the board of directors of the American Medical Association [is] only made up of bureaucrats and no doctors".

Collins said the Vatican administration routinely ignored the commission's recommendations, even though they had the backing of Pope Francis.

He voiced his gratitude to her for her willingness to continue working with the commission, specifically "in the education of church leaders", including upcoming courses for new bishops and departments of the Holy See.

The sole Irish member of the Pope's child protection commission has stepped down, three years after joining the Vatican body. "Our prayers will remain with Marie and with all victims and survivors of sexual abuse", the cardinal wrote. She said she thought the problems had more to do with turf battles within the church than ideological or theological arguments, though she said that as an outsider it was hard to be sure.

Related news:

Hot News

Browns Listening To Offers For First Overall Pick
Mar 03, 2017 - 01:09
The Browns will have that opportunity with players across all positions this week as they fine-tune their draft board. It was his first season as a receiver; he had entered the National Football League as a quarterback in 2011.

Spotify Moves On Hi-Res Streaming
Mar 03, 2017 - 01:06
As the below image shows, some of the ads indicate Hi-Fi will also include a free vinyl record and discounts on vinyl purchases. Spotify is reportedly working hard on providing high fidelity music for its subscribers and is now studying the pricing.

isis-killer-beheading-video-story-top Macedonia's President Refuses To Give Opposition Leader Mandate For New Government
Mar 02, 2017 - 00:53
Zaev is sticking to implementing Edi Rama's platform and his coalition with DUI, BESA, and the alliance for albanians. Ivanov adds that at a meeting with Zaev he proposed him to carry out consultations with the Albanian parties.

What is the Sell-side Saying About Lattice Semiconductor Corporation (NASDAQ:LSCC)?
Mar 02, 2017 - 00:52
Mizuho restated their buy rating on shares of Cypress Semiconductor Corporation (NASDAQ:CY) in a report issued on Tuesday morning. Following the transaction, the chief financial officer now directly owns 181,606 shares in the company, valued at $2,148,398.98.

Border wall construction to start 'soon'
Mar 02, 2017 - 00:52
Trump has consistently said Mexico will ultimately pay for the new wall, while Mexican officials have firmly rejected that idea. The agency won't post a formal request for bids until March 6, with conceptual designs due on March 10.

isis-killer-beheading-video-story-top NFL Scouting Combine Preview, Where To Watch
Mar 02, 2017 - 00:49
The early part of their trip is filled with medical and psychological testing, along with team meetings and media availability. As fans, the National Football League gives us an interesting, though only partial, view into everything that goes on there.

isis-killer-beheading-video-story-top Trump to outline spending plans in speech to Congress
Mar 02, 2017 - 00:49
Thankfully, cartoon Trump, with a clownish red tie tied too long, didn't show up to address a joint session of Congress Tuesday. President Donald Trump speaks during a meeting with House and Senate leadership on Wednesday at the White House.

isis-killer-beheading-video-story-top LG to debut its own virtual reality SteamVR headset at GDC 2017
Mar 02, 2017 - 00:46
And, like we said, it will be based around the SteamVR system, which was opened to developers and manufacturers a year ago . Also, LG has experimented with VR in the past - like when it launched the 360 VR headset for LG G5 flagship.

Iraqi Commander: Troops push further into western Mosul
Mar 01, 2017 - 00:45
Those still in Mosul have to face Daesh's strict rule along with a lack of basic goods and the danger from the fighting. On Tuesday, the Iraqi army began evacuating displaced people from the village of al Salam, south-west of the airport.

isis-killer-beheading-video-story-top SpaceX to fly two tourists to the moon
Mar 01, 2017 - 00:44
Musk didn't say much about the two unidentified passengers, let alone how much money they're shelling out for their Moon voyage. Musk, for his part, also said his company's achievements would not be possible without NASA's full support.

Government urged to approve life-changing drugs to treat rare diseases
Mar 01, 2017 - 00:44
Rare diseases and disorders are less likely to receive the funding and awareness required to accelerate research. There are 70 million rare disease patients in India and 350 million rare disease patients worldwide.

Drug suspects cut way out of Philippines police facility
Mar 01, 2017 - 00:44
President Duterte stopped the "war on drugs" when it was discovered that some police scalawags in the likes of SPO3 Ricky Sta. He tapped PDEA, with the help of the military, to be the lead agency in the campaign against the drug menace.

isis-killer-beheading-video-story-top U.S. probing whether Al-Qaeda number two killed in Syria
Mar 01, 2017 - 00:43
Photos posted on social media show a auto with a gaping hole in its roof after the attack but its windscreen mostly intact. Also on the post was the picture of several rescuers trying to get the body out of the vehicle.

isis-killer-beheading-video-story-top Togo worldwide footballer saves goalkeeper's life on pitch
Mar 01, 2017 - 00:42
Bohemians goalkeeper Martin Berkovec immediately appeared to be in trouble after colliding with defender Daniel Krch . Thankfully, the quick reaction of Slovacko striker Francis Kone saved the goalkeeper's life right there on the pitch.

How a Holocaust Historian Was Nearly Deported From the US
Mar 01, 2017 - 00:41
Young to enlist the help of Texas A&M Law School professor and director of the Immigrant Rights Clinic Fatma Marouf. He was born in Egypt but moved to France aged two, after his family was expelled from the country in 1956.